On 7/14/2017 9:29 AM, Steve Zingman wrote:
OK, So this "discussion" has go on for about a week.
The following comments are mine - and not of AllStarLink Inc. I see that the HamVoip distribution 1.5 has telemetry ducking. This feature set was designed by me and implemented by a friend into a different distribution. I paid to have this done, and understood that it would be made available to the public by the terms of Open Source. If HamVoip doesn't make their entire source code available, I will be informing Digium of this violation. While Digium no longer supports the app_rpt application, they certainly do the Asterisk Project. If the HamVoip folks haven't signed an agreement, then shame on them. Just because Digium is no longer supporting this application doesn't mean they don't still own it. It's still under Digium's control, and using any part of Asterisk obligates them to follow the terms of Open Source: https://wiki.asterisk.org/wiki/display/AST/License+Information If HamVoip had their own commercial license, they would be making people sign an agreement for its use. I'm not aware of any such requirement. If Digium doesn't enforce the terms of Open Source, I'll be heading up a team (outside AllStarLink Inc.) that will. This is wrong - plain and simple. It goes against everything that Jim Dixon, Steve RoDgers, and Steve Henke (among others) have done. I don't use HamVoip for several reasons. Some of these reasons are personal, just like this situation that begs questioning as to why they wont release it. Are they hiding something? Are they planning to use it for-profit? They certainly are willing to take credit for code they didn't write, and that's not right.... All releases of Asterisk and app_rpt have (or should have) included in the header of the code the licensing requirements. I'm not just making this up, go have a look at the (real) source code for yourself. Those of you wanting them to release it, keep bugging them. If they continue to deny the requests, let me know - duuuude! Kevin Custer - W3KKC